UK Home Secretary Moves to Address Concerns Over Two-Tier Policing
UK Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood has announced plans to strengthen guidance on police impartiality, in an effort to address what she describes as a growing public perception that some people are treated differently by police because of their political views or background.
Speaking at a conference of police chiefs on Wednesday, Mahmood said a new national standard was being developed to ensure members of the public receive equal treatment under the law.
She warned police leaders against what she called misguided attempts to correct inequalities if those efforts result in different treatment for different groups.
The announcement comes amid increasing political debate over allegations of so-called two-tier policing in the United Kingdom. Much of the recent criticism has come from politicians and commentators on the political right, who argue that police forces apply the law differently depending on a person’s race, beliefs or political position.
Reform UK leader Nigel Farage has claimed that white people are treated differently by police because of their race. However, critics argue that such claims risk overlooking the experiences of black and other minority ethnic communities, who have raised concerns about unequal treatment by law enforcement for many years.
One incident frequently cited in the debate involved the arrest of Henry Nowak while he was dying after being stabbed by Vickrum Digwa, who had accused him of racism. The case has become part of wider arguments about whether police officers apply their powers consistently.
However, some senior police figures have strongly rejected claims that there is a system of two-tier policing.
Mahmood began her address by praising the courage and commitment of police officers but acknowledged that public confidence in policing was declining.
She said the actions of a minority had allowed people to promote what she described as a false narrative that police forces operate different standards for different sections of society.
The home secretary stressed that most officers already carry out their duties impartially and that policing without fear or favour remains a fundamental principle of the profession.
She called for clear and comprehensive guidance to reinforce the responsibility of officers to apply the law consistently, regardless of a person’s identity, political beliefs or background.
Mahmood also addressed how police officers should engage with local communities. She said community engagement should involve ordinary activities such as attending residents’ association meetings and speaking with members of the public, rather than becoming involved with activists seeking to advance particular political agendas.
“Leave the politics to the politicians,” she told police chiefs, adding that policing should remain the responsibility of officers.
Despite her concerns about public confidence, Mahmood said inequalities within police forces still needed to be addressed. She highlighted the persistently low representation of black officers and said racism had no place in policing.
She also referred to racist behaviour previously exposed at Charing Cross Police Station, describing it as unacceptable.
However, the home secretary questioned whether some well-intentioned equality initiatives had unintentionally weakened confidence in police impartiality.
She specifically raised concerns about approaches such as the Police Anti-Racism Commitment, arguing that efforts to improve equality must not lead to different standards of treatment.
Mahmood said her own background as a Muslim home secretary did not change her commitment to tackling discrimination, but stressed that fairness must apply equally to everyone.
The Conservative Party responded to the announcement by saying it had been raising concerns about unequal treatment for years.
Shadow Home Secretary Chris Philp said Mahmood had finally acknowledged that a problem existed and that his party would judge the government on whether its commitments resulted in meaningful changes.
Meanwhile, Jo Noakes, who leads the College of Policing, the organisation responsible for setting professional standards for police forces, said new guidance on impartiality would be issued in the spring.
Noakes said maintaining public confidence depended on officers and police staff exercising their powers without fear or favour.
She also stressed that impartiality should be considered alongside fairness and inclusion, both within police organisations and in their dealings with the public.
The proposed guidance is expected to provide officers with clearer direction on how to maintain impartiality while addressing concerns about discrimination and public trust.
The debate over two-tier policing has become a significant political issue, with disagreements continuing over how police forces should balance equal treatment, tackling racism and maintaining public confidence.
Mahmood’s announcement seeks to reinforce the principle that the law must be applied consistently, while making clear that efforts to address inequalities should not undermine the impartiality expected of every police officer.


